Pros of S.O.F. kayaks
What it is and what it isn't
The best thing since sliced bröd got an upgrade?
âŠYeah, no. (But apparently you're still reading, so welcome, fellow over-thinker.)
What IS a Skin On Frame kayak? It is what the Inuit hunters built to catch sea animals for sustenance in the harsh environment after the last global icecap receeded. History books tells us they have been living in the area for 1000 years or so but logically, seal hunting and fishing has gone on at the edge of the inland ice for as long as humanity has needed food to survive. I digress.
The SOF construction is simply put a wooden frame, covered with seal skin. The hows and whys I leave for another article.
I mostly paddle low-volume roll kayaks, so yeah⊠it gets noticeably wetter. Your ass might not thank you during the winter season. On the other hand: super easy to carry around and throw on the roof, reliable in winter conditions (no moving parts, like hatches or skeg), you can drop it, stack it, or yeet it off the car roof without having a heart attack.
Itâs stupidly fun in wind and waves â catches a plane/surfs like itâs on a mission. Iâm on my 9th SOF build now and the last two have actually turned out pretty damn decent at both paddling and rolling. Building a classic skeg boat or a pure roll-specialist kayak? Way easier, honestly. But trying to make something truly neutral â one that turns sweetly, handles well in wind, and just does everything decently without sucking at any one thing? That's the real bastard of a challenge.
With solid plans and good guidance, you can pull it off.
Or... you can go the mad-scientist route like I did: experiment a ton, build a bunch of kayaks, rebuild, then rebuild again and slowly figure it out the hard way. That path takes serious patience, time, dedication, and probably at least a couple books on hydrodynamics (or aero, depending on how windy your life is).
The materials themselves aren't that expensive, but buying decent tools will hit your wallet harder than the first few boats ever will. Then there's all the time spent testing them in every condition imaginable â flat calm, big waves, side winds, moving water, you name it. And yeah, all that time is money too. So pick your poison: follow a proven recipe and get something good fast, or chase the perfect all-rounder and enjoy (or suffer) the long, glorious learning curve. Either way, it's addictive.
I started with museum replica drawings, then slowly drifted away from the lines while keeping the good bones. Still, Iâm just a good padawan around here, not The Master đ If you get the chance, come try mine, seriously!
Downsides
The SOF kayak really doesnât like getting ground down in the same spot bow & stern when you do beach landings all the time. Keel tape? Wonât stick. Easy fix though: slap on a simple, cheap, replaceable keel strip you screw on from the outside.
My roll boats mostly want to carry nothing but a tiny thermos⊠but you can fix that with a removable âIserfikâ bulkhead behind the seat. Boom â suddenly thereâs room for your sandwich too! If youâre dreaming of a touring kayak? Meh, not much advantage here except maybe weight. Fully loaded itâll probably end up about the same weight as a glassfibre equivalent anyway.
Quick reality check: every kayak is a compromise. Dead simple to build something that turns on a dime⊠but then it sucks without a skeg and you constantly have to adjust it, instead of enjoying the scenery or trying to survive. You can actually tune a boat to be neutral in wind when you're building â even decide how much wind it likes before it starts weathercocking or running away downwind. But then trying to also get nice release at the stern (no big slop), decent carving turns (not just skidding), good rolling, comfy seat, doesnât broach in every tiny surf, stable enough, lively enough⊠yeah, thatâs the hard part. And thatâs exactly why youâve gotta build and try as many as you can, right?
Oh, and the thing people obsess over, how âfastâ it is, you better just forget. So much bloody yapping about hull speed on the internet. Way more important that your kayak feels easy and light at the speed you actually enjoy paddling.
And who the hell am I to have all these opinions anyway? Guy whoâs loved whitewater, surfski, fitness canoes⊠and has probably tried 30+ sea kayaks more than just once. About 10 years ago I decided I wanted to be able to roll whatever I get into, preferably without a paddle (which you can lose). Had horrible tennis elbow + wrist pain for ages⊠switched to Greenland paddle and poof, pain gone.
Iâm not selling any religion here, no âthis is the only wayâ bullshit. Just paddle whatâs fun for you. And please donât listen to know-it-alls (yes, including me).
Go try shit yourself and figure out what YOU like! Roast me in the comments, I just might enjoy helping you to join the dark side!